Welcome to Papa Joe's Pizza & Italian Restaurant
Papa Joe's Pizza & Italian Restaurant, located in Lake Mary, Florida, brings a slice of Italy to the heart of the community. Known for its warm atmosphere and welcoming staff, it's a favorite for families and couples alike. The menu boasts delightful options, from seafood dishes like Pesce Oreganta to the mouthwatering Shrimp Parmigiana over linguini. Renowned for its authentic, New York-style pizza, patrons rave about the friendly service and pet-friendly patio. With a commitment to quality and customer satisfaction, Papa Joe’s creates memorable dining experiences, making it the perfect destination for any occasion. Whether you're here for a casual meal or a celebration, you'll leave satisfied and eager to return.
Papa Joe's Pizza & Italian Restaurant: Reviews & Ratings
Had a night before the wedding celebration and it turned out amazing! Casual, fun, and delicious! Thanks Jason, Pam, Kim and staff! 5 stars! Plus I planned it from out of town... they made it easy!
Stopped in for a late dinner with friends as we were traveling through the area. We were with our 2 small dogs and sat on the patio. The food was good, and the service was good too. We didn’t feel rushed even though it was close to closing time. They were able to serve our dogs unseasoned grilled chicken and take some to go as well. Very pet friendly, glad we stopped here
Love this place always great service and a great atmosphere. It’s a great family place or date night. Which ever one you pick you won’t go wrong. Bon appetite
Absolutely amazing PIZZA! The Best in the area! Dawson was by far, the sweetest and most responsive server! We are from Daytona and will definitely be back. I'm from NJ, so good pizza will always bring me back!
Stopped in to grab a slice while waiting for our movie next door. Staff was great and very responsive as well as promt. Beer was very good and was priced better then the other surrounding places. The pizza was great and has the NYC taste to it. Didn’t try much else but very anxious to try again. Maybe next time I’ll try the dinners out. Over all A
In town for a baseball tournament and found Papa Joes by accident. Great food, great atmosphere, and the service was top notch. This is our place now every time we come back!!!
Hubby and I had medium cheese pizza with extra cheese and man they did not disappoint! It has a ton of cheese super stretchy and delicious!!! Amazing service as well!!! Ryan is an amazing waiter
Went to get a take out white pizza before closing and it was fantastic! Highly recommend. The staff was kind and food was delish! Treat yo self to the bianco za next time you are in Lake Mary.
Location
-
960 Colonial Grand Ln, Lake Mary, FL 32746, United States Hotline: +1 407-936-3300
Welcome to Papa Joe's Pizza & Italian Restaurant! Nestled in the heart of Lake Mary, Florida, at 960 Colonial Grand Ln, this charming establishment draws food lovers with a promise of authentic Italian cuisine and a warm, inviting atmosphere.
At Papa Joe's, you’ll discover a menu bursting with flavor and a rich selection of dishes that pay homage to Italian culinary traditions. Their lunch menu features delectable offerings, including:
- Seafood – Dive into their Marinara Sauce served over linguini for just $16.95, or savor the divine Snapper or Salmon Oreganata, lightly breaded with a zesty white wine and lemon sauce for $24.95.
- Salads – Refresh yourself with the Antipasto Salad, loaded with a choice of eight dressings that cater to every preference, all for only $11.50.
- Stromboli & Calzones – Try the hearty Stromboli, generously filled with traditional pizza ingredients for just $12.50, or enjoy a classic Cheese Calzone paired with their house sauce for $11.00.
But the experience at Papa Joe's goes beyond just food. Customers rave about the welcoming and friendly service that permeates every corner of this restaurant. As one guest, Roberta Trowbridge, describes, there’s an undeniable charm for celebrations, making it a perfect location for both family gatherings and romantic evenings alike. "Casual, fun, and delicious!" she says, highlighting how the staff effortlessly contributes to a memorable dining experience.
What’s more, Papa Joe’s extends its hospitality to furry companions too! Daniel Fernandez shared his delight at being able to dine on the patio with his two small dogs, enjoying a late meal without feeling rushed, while also having meals specially prepared for his pets.
And let's talk about the pizza! Many diners, including Loni Dunlap, declare it as the best in the area. The richness of flavors and the New York-style quality make it a must-try, drawing patrons even from far-away locations. As noted by Mike’s Lab, the responsive service coupled with an extensive beer selection adds to a remarkable dining experience.
In conclusion, Papa Joe's Pizza & Italian Restaurant is not just a place to eat; it's a culinary experience that combines delectable food, a friendly environment, and attentive service. Whether you're a local or just passing through, this gem is worth your time—and your appetite!
For a taste of Italy paired with the warmth of community, visit them today or call for info at +1 407-936-3300. Bon appétit!